The Case of the Crowded Client
After I made my video player that I planned to use to illustrate refactoring a non-design pattern program into a design pattern one, I noticed how crowded the Client class had become. Most of the crowding was caused by creating and populating UIs and event handling functions. One class that I use a lot to populate UI components is the DataProvider. As I went through and edited and organized my videos from a vacation to Prague, CZ, the DataProvider kept growing. Using MP4 files converted into F4V files, I used very similar formats for the data portion of all of the DataProvider instance. Why not put the DataProvider data into a separate class? Then, I could just call an instance of the class with the data and not have to clutter the Client class with messy DataProvider information.
Lazy Programming can be a Lot of Work
After moving the DataProvider data to another class, I realized that I had two other projects using the video player that accessed the same kind of data. So, while I was at it, I might as well add classes for these other projects. In fact, why not add a common interface as well? Then I could program all data requests to the interface instead of the implementation. Further, I could add some separation between the DataProvider items and the Client requests by adding a factory, and if I were going to do that, I might as well go ahead and create a Factory Method design pattern. Then, whenever I wanted to add a class with data for different projects I could do so without having to worry about messing up the rest of the program. Each project was handled using a Concrete Product class.
The Big Picture
To begin with a clear idea of what is going on in this refactoring exercise, you’ll need to get the big picture. Figure 1 provides an overview of how the video player is to be refactored using two design patterns:

The video player is essentially a state machine, and in Part II of this post, we’ll look at how we’ll refactor the hack-job player into a state player.
Continue reading ‘Friends with Benefits: Refactoring with Multiple Design Patterns—Part I’


Bill Sanders
Recent Comments